Custom Cash vs Blue Cash Everyday
Which card wins depends on the category you choose: Citi Custom Cash pays the bonus rate in a category you pick, and the table below shows base rates only. Pick the card whose bonus lands where you spend the most. Neither card has an annual fee.
Updated November 16, 2026 · from RightCard's verified card and merchant data
Counting categories is not the same as counting your spend: the winner for you is the one that wins where your money goes.
Every category, side by side
Published everyday rates. For points cards the value in brackets uses our conservative travel estimate; as cash, points are worth 1¢. No welcome bonuses, no limited-time offers.
| Category | Custom Cash | Blue Cash Everyday | Wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Restaurants | 1x points (1.6¢) | 1% | Custom Cash |
| Supermarkets | 1x points (1.6¢) | 3% | Blue Cash Everyday |
| Gas stations | 1x points (1.6¢) | 3% | Blue Cash Everyday |
| Travel | 1x points (1.6¢) | 1% | Custom Cash |
| Online shopping | 1x points (1.6¢) | 3% | Blue Cash Everyday |
| Drugstores | 1x points (1.6¢) | 1% | Custom Cash |
| Transit & rideshare | 1x points (1.6¢) | 1% | Custom Cash |
| Streaming | 1x points (1.6¢) | 1% | Custom Cash |
| Everything else | 1x points (1.6¢) | 1% | Custom Cash |
Point values: Custom Cash: Citi ThankYou Points at 1.6¢ toward travel. Cash out and most points are worth 1¢ or less.
Fee and credits
| Card | Annual fee | Statement credits | Credits, face value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Custom Cash | no annual fee | none verified | — |
| Blue Cash Everyday | no annual fee | Disney Streaming Credit ($7 monthly) | $84 / yr |
Credits count only if you would spend there anyway. Tick the ones you would use and get each card's fee verdict →
Carrying both
Together they cover 9 of 9 categories above the other card's rate. See the pair as one wallet, then add the rest of your cards.
Citi Custom Cash in full → · American Express Blue Cash Everyday in full →
Sources
- Citi Custom Cash: the card's own page on citi.com
- American Express Blue Cash Everyday: the card's own page on americanexpress.com
- CFPB credit card agreement database: every bank's card agreements as filed with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Visa Merchant Data Standards Manual: the merchant category codes a store is filed under
- Point values: The Points Guy, Frequent Miler, Upgraded Points, One Mile at a Time. We use the middle value, rounded down (how).
Get RightCard on the App Store
FAQ
Custom Cash or Blue Cash Everyday: which earns more?
Which card wins depends on the category you choose: Citi Custom Cash pays the bonus rate in a category you pick, and the table below shows base rates only. Pick the card whose bonus lands where you spend the most. Neither card has an annual fee.
Which has the lower annual fee, Custom Cash or Blue Cash Everyday?
Neither card has an annual fee.
Should I get both?
Only if each wins a category you spend in. Together they lead in 9 of 9 categories; the rate-my-wallet tool shows the pair as one wallet.
More guides: All comparisons · Rate my wallet · Every verified card
