Hilton Honors Surpass vs Gold Card

For most spending, pick American Express Gold Card: it earns more than Hilton Honors Surpass in 8 of 9 categories. Hilton Honors Surpass is better only for gas stations and its built-in rate at Hilton Honors. Annual fees: $325 for Gold Card, $150 for Hilton Honors Surpass.

By

Updated November 16, 2026 · from RightCard's verified card and merchant data

Counting categories is not the same as counting your spend: the winner for you is the one that wins where your money goes.

Every category, side by side

Published everyday rates. For points cards the value in brackets uses our conservative travel estimate; as cash, points are worth 1¢. No welcome bonuses, no limited-time offers.

CategoryHilton Honors SurpassGold CardWins
Restaurants6x points (2.4¢)4x points (7.2¢)Gold Card
Supermarkets6x points (2.4¢)4x points (7.2¢)Gold Card
Gas stations6x points (2.4¢)1x points (1.8¢)Hilton Honors Surpass
Travel3x points (1.2¢)1x points (1.8¢)Gold Card
Online shopping4x points (1.6¢)1x points (1.8¢)Gold Card
Drugstores3x points (1.2¢)1x points (1.8¢)Gold Card
Transit & rideshare3x points (1.2¢)1x points (1.8¢)Gold Card
Streaming3x points (1.2¢)1x points (1.8¢)Gold Card
Everything else3x points (1.2¢)1x points (1.8¢)Gold Card

Point values: Hilton Honors Surpass: Hilton Honors at 0.4¢ toward travel; Gold Card: Amex Membership Rewards at 1.8¢ toward travel. Cash out and most points are worth 1¢ or less.

Fee and credits

CardAnnual feeStatement creditsCredits, face value
Hilton Honors Surpass$150 feeHilton credit ($50 quarterly)$200 / yr
Gold Card$325 feeDining credit ($10 monthly), Resy credit ($50 twice a year), Dunkin' credit ($7 monthly)$304 / yr

Credits count only if you would spend there anyway. Tick the ones you would use and get each card's fee verdict →

Built-in store rates

CardStoreRate
Hilton Honors SurpassHilton Hotels & Resorts12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHilton Honors12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHilton Garden Inn12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHampton by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHampton Inn12%
Hilton Honors SurpassDoubleTree by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassEmbassy Suites by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHomewood Suites by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHomewood Suites12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHome2 Suites by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassHome2 Suites12%
Hilton Honors SurpassTru by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassCanopy by Hilton12%
Hilton Honors SurpassWaldorf Astoria Hotels & Resorts12%
Hilton Honors SurpassWaldorf Astoria, Conrad, & Lxr12%
Hilton Honors SurpassGraduate Hotels12%

Carrying both

Together they cover 9 of 9 categories above the other card's rate. See the pair as one wallet, then add the rest of your cards.

Hilton Honors Surpass in full → · American Express Gold Card in full →

Sources

How RightCard handles this: add both cards and the app picks between them at every store, with your bank offers and this quarter's rotating bonus folded in. The app is free and private. No bank login. Recommendations are computed on your phone.

Get RightCard on the App Store

FAQ

Hilton Honors Surpass or Gold Card: which earns more?

For most spending, pick American Express Gold Card: it earns more than Hilton Honors Surpass in 8 of 9 categories. Hilton Honors Surpass is better only for gas stations and its built-in rate at Hilton Honors. Annual fees: $325 for Gold Card, $150 for Hilton Honors Surpass.

Which has the lower annual fee, Hilton Honors Surpass or Gold Card?

Hilton Honors Surpass has the lower fee: $150 a year, against $325 for Gold Card.

Should I get both?

Only if each wins a category you spend in. Together they lead in 9 of 9 categories; the rate-my-wallet tool shows the pair as one wallet.

Where these numbers come from: RightCard's data pipeline re-checks each card's published rates weekly and lists a rate only after two independent sources agree. Merchant codes come from our merchant directory. If a card or store is missing here, it is because we could not verify it, not because we guessed.

More guides: All comparisons · Rate my wallet · Every verified card